You are here

Slip Opinion 2020

Note: The Court works to ensure the timeliness and accuracy of this information. However, researchers should independently verify the status of the opinions as well as their precedential value and note that the slip opinions filed on the Court's CM/ECF system are the official court documents of record.

Having trouble viewing PDF documents?

Number

Caption

Date

Court No.

Judge

Jurisdiction

20-189 YC Rubber Co. (North Am.) LLC v. United States 12/22/2020 Consol. 19-00069 Barnett 1581(c)
20-188 Plexus Corp. v. United States 12/22/2020 13-00343 Reif 1581(a)
20-187 Calgon Carbon Corp. v. United States 12/21/2020 Consol. 18-00232 Barnett 1581(c)
20-186 Hilex Poly Co. v. United States 12/21/2020 17-00090 Stanceu 1581(i)
20-185 American Drew v. United States 12/21/2020 17-00086 Stanceu 1581(i)
20-184 Adee Honey Farms v. United States 12/21/2020 Consol. 16-00127 Stanceu 1581(i)
20-183 Linyi Chengen Imp. & Exp. Co. v. United States 12/21/2020 Consol. 18-00002 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-182 Shandong Yongtai Grp. Co. v. United States 12/21/2020 Consol. 18-00077 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-181 Saha Thai Steel Pipe Pub. Co. v. United States 12/21/2020 Consol. 18-00214 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-180 NTSF Seafoods Joint Stock Co. v. United States 12/21/2020 19-00063 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-179 Bio-Lab, Inc. v. United States 12/18/2020 19-00158 Eaton 1581(c)
20-178 Jiangsu Senmao Bamboo & Wood Indus. Co. v. United States 12/10/2020 Consol. 15-00225 Stanceu 1581(c)
20-177 Transpacific Steel LLC v. United States 12/09/2020 19-00009 Kelly, Katzmann, Restani 1581(i)
20-176 Celik Halat ve Tel Sanayi A.S. v. United States 12/06/2020 20-03848 Kelly 1581(i)
20-175 Celik Halat ve Tel Sanayi A.S. v. United States 12/06/2020 20-03843 Kelly 1581(i)
20-174 Hung Vuong Corp. v. United States 12/03/2020 19-00055 Baker 1581(c)
20-173 Manchester Tank & Equip. Co. v. United States 12/03/2020 19-00147 Barnett 1581(c)
20-172 Wilmar Trading PTE Ltd. v. United States 12/01/2020 Consol. 18-00006 Eaton 1581(c)
20-171 Royal Brush Mfg., Inc. v. United States 12/01/2020 19-00198 Barnett 1581(c)
20-170 Novolipetsk Steel Pub. Joint Stock Co. v. United States
Public version posted 12/09/2020.
11/30/2020 19-00172 Kelly 1581(c)
20-169 TMB 440AE, Inc. v. United States
Public version posted 11/27/2020.
11/27/2020 18-00095 Restani 1581(c)
20-168 Hyundai Steel Co. v. United States 11/23/2020 Consol. 18-00154 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-167 Comm. Overseeing Action for Lumber Int'l Trade Investigations or Negotiations v. United States 11/19/2020 Consol. 19-00122 Barnett 1581(i)
20-166 Invenergy Renewables LLC v. United States 11/19/2020 19-00192 Katzmann 1581(i)
20-165 Hyundai Heavy Indus. Co. v. United States
Public version posted 11/25/2020.
11/18/2020 Consol. 18-00066 Barnett 1581(c)
20-164 StarKist Co. v. United States
Errata: 12/01/2020.
11/18/2020 14-00068 Reif 1581(a)
20-163 Pro-Team Coil Nail Enter., Inc. v. United States 11/16/2020 Consol. 18-00027 Barnett 1581(c)
20-162 Intercontinental Chems., LLC v. United States 11/12/2020 20-00068 Reif 1581(i)
20-161 Nippon Steel & Sumitomo Metal Corp. v. United States
Public version posted 11/18/2020.
11/10/2020 19-00131 Reif 1581(c)
20-160 Hyundai Elec. & Energy Sys. Co. v. United States 11/09/2020 20-00108 Barnett 1581(c)
20-159 Jinxiang Infang Fruit & Vegetable Co. v. United States 11/05/2020 19-00211 Gordon 1581(c)
20-158 Carpenter Tech. Corp. v. United States 11/04/2020 19-00200 Barnett 1581(c)
20-157 Full Member Subgroup of the Am. Inst. of Steel Constr., LLC v. United States 11/03/2020 20-00089 Kelly 1581(c)
20-156 Full Member Subgroup of the Am. Inst. of Steel Constr., LLC v. United States 11/03/2020 20-00088 Kelly 1581(c)
20-155 Bldg. Sys. de Mexico, S.A. de C.V. v. United States 11/03/2020 20-00069 Kelly 1581(c)
20-154 United States v. NYWL Enter. Inc. 10/30/2020 16-00257 Barnett 1582
20-153 Hyundai Elec. & Energy Sys. Co. v. United States
Public version posted 11/06/2020.
10/30/2020 20-00108 Barnett 1581(c)
20-152 Risen Energy Co. v. United States
Public version posted 11/10/2020.
10/30/2020 Consol. 19-00153 Kelly 1581(c)
20-151 Uttam Galva Steels Ltd. v. United States 10/29/2020 19-00044 Gordon 1581(c)
20-150 SGS Sports Inc. v. United States 10/22/2020 18-00128 Choe-Groves 1581(a)
20-149 Canadian Solar Inc. v. United States 10/19/2020 Consol. 18-00184 Restani 1581(c)
20-148 Saha Thai Steel Pipe Pub. Co. v. United States 10/19/2020 19-00208 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-147 Husteel Co. v. United States 10/19/2020 Consol. 19-00107 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-146 Vandewater Int'l, Inc. v. United States 10/16/2020 18-00199 Gordon 1581(c)
20-145 NEXTEEL Co. v. United States 10/16/2020 Consol. 18-00083 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-144 Invenergy Renewables LLC v. United States 10/15/2020 19-00192 Katzmann 1581(i)
20-143 Bourgault Indus., Ltd. v. United States 10/13/2020 19-00111 Eaton 1581(c)
20-142 Novolipetsk Steel Public Joint Stock Co. v. United States 10/08/2020 20-00031 Kelly 1581(c)
20-141 Clearon Corp. v. United States 10/08/2020 Consol. 17-00171 Eaton 1581(c)
20-140 Echjay Forgings Pvt. Ltd. v. United States
Public version posted 10/08/2020.
10/08/2020 18-00230 Katzmann 1581(c)
20-139 Dong-A Steel Co. v. United States
Public version posted 10/01/2020.
09/29/2020 Consol. 19-00104 Katzmann 1581(c)
20-138 Taizhou United Imp. & Exp. Co. v. United States 09/25/2020 Consol. 16-00009 Gordon 1581(c)
20-137 Icdas Celik Enerji Tersane Ve Ulasim Sanayi, A.S. v. United States 09/23/2020 Consol. 18-00143 Katzmann 1581(c)
20-136 Transpacific Steel LLC v. United States 09/15/2020 19-00009 Kelly, Katzmann, Restani 1581(i)
20-135 Sao Ta Foods Joint Stock Co. v. United States
Public version posted 09/23/2020.
09/15/2020 Consol. 18-00205 Kelly 1581(c)
20-134 Canadian Solar Int'l Ltd. v. United States 09/14/2020 Consol. 17-00173 Kelly 1581(c)
20-133 Jem D Int'l (Michigan) Inc. USA v. United States 09/11/2020 19-00127 Choe-Groves 1581(i)
20-132 Bioparques de Occidente, S.A. de C.V. v. United States 09/11/2020 19-00204, 19-00210, 20-00035 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-131 Habaş Sinai ve Tibbi Gazlar Istihsal Endüstrisi, A.Ş. v. United States 09/04/2020 Consol. 17-00204 Barnett 1581(c)
20-130 Cyber Power Sys. (USA) Inc. v. United States 09/02/2020 20-00124 Gordon 1581(a)
20-129 Columbia Aluminum Prods., LLC v. United States 08/27/2020 19-00013 Stanceu 1581(c)
20-128 Worldwide Door Components, Inc. v. United States
Errata: 08/28/2020.
08/27/2020 19-00012 Stanceu 1581(c)
20-127 Coal. for Fair Trade in Garlic v. United States 08/27/2020 18-00137 Barnett 1581(c)
20-126 Red Sun Farms v. United States 08/26/2020 19-00205 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-125 Husteel Co. v. United States 08/26/2020 Consol. 19-00112 Kelly 1581(c)
20-124 United Steel & Fasteners, Inc. v. United States 08/26/2020 15-00113 Katzmann 1581(c)
20-123 Kent Int'l, Inc. v. United States 08/25/2020 15-00135 Gordon 1581(a)
20-122 Zhejiang Mach. Imp. & Exp. Corp. v. United States
Public version posted 08/21/2020.
08/21/2020 19-00039 Katzmann 1581(c)
20-121 Fabuwood Cabinetry Corp. v. United States 08/19/2020 Consol. 18-00208 Katzmann 1581(c)
20-120 Aspects Furniture Int'l, Inc. v. United States 08/17/2020 18-00222 Barnett 1581(a)
20-119 Spirit AeroSystems, Inc. v. United States 08/17/2020 20-00094 Kelly 1581(a)
20-118 Venus Wire Indus. Pvt. Ltd. v. United States
Public version posted 08/24/2020.
08/14/2020 18-00113 Barnett 1581(c)
20-117 Guizhou Tyre Co. v. United States 08/14/2020 Consol. 18-00099 Stanceu 1581(c)
20-116 Sea Shepherd New Zealand v. United States 08/13/2020 20-00112 Katzmann 1581(i)
20-115 Wilmar Trading Pte Ltd. v. United States 08/11/2020 Consol. 18-00006 Eaton 1581(c)
20-114 Star Pipe Prods. v. United States 08/11/2020 17-00236 Stanceu 1581(c) & 1581(i)
20-113 SGS Sports, Inc. v. United States 08/07/2020 18-00128 Choe-Groves 1581(a)
20-112 Danze, Inc. v. United States 08/07/2020 15-00033 et al. Barnett 1581(a)
20-111 JSW Steel (USA) Inc. v. United States 08/05/2020 19-00133 Kelly 1581(i)
20-110 Hyundai Electric & Energy Sys. Co. v. United States
Public version posted 08/13/2020.
08/04/2020 19-00058 Barnett 1581(c)
20-109 Changzhou Trina Solar Energy Co. v. United States 08/04/2020 Consol. 17-00246 Restani 1581(c)
20-108 Changzhou Trina Solar Energy Co. v. United States 08/04/2020 Consol. 17-00198 Restani 1581(c)
20-107 Yama Ribbons and Bows Co., Ltd. v. United States 07/31/2020 18-00054 Stanceu 1581(c)
20-106 Vietnam Finewood Co. v. United States 07/31/2020 19-00218 Barnett 1581(i)
20-105 Tosçelik Profil ve Sac Endüstrisi A.Ş. v. United States 07/28/2020 Consol. 17-00018 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-104 Bldg. Sys. de Mexico, S.A. de C.V. v. United States 07/23/2020 20-00069 Kelly 1581(c)
20-103 Husteel Co. v. United States 07/23/2020 Consol. 18-00169 Kelly 1581(c)
20-102 Jiaxing Brother Fastener Co. v. United States
Public version posted 07/30/2020.
07/22/2020 14-00316 Kelly 1581(c)
20-101 Perry Chem. Corp. v. United States
Public version posted 07/30/2020.
07/22/2020 15-00168 Kelly 1581(i)
20-100 United States v. Greenlight Organic, Inc. 07/14/2020 17-00031 Choe-Groves 1582
20-99 Jindal Poly Films Ltd. of India v. United States 07/14/2020 19-00043 Gordon 1581(c)
20-98 Transpacific Steel LLC v. United States 07/14/2020 19-00009 Kelly, Katzmann, Restani 1581(i)
20-97 Bosun Tools Co. v. United States 07/14/2020 Consol. 18-00102 Kelly 1581(c)
20-96 Magnum Magnetics Corp. v. United States 07/13/2020 19-00126 Restani 1581(c)
20-95 United States v. Cruzin Cooler, LLC 07/09/2020 15-00333 Reif 1582
20-94 Navigator Co., S.A. v. United States 07/07/2020 Consol. 18-00192 Barnett 1581(c)
20-93 Confederación de Asociaciones Agrícolas del Estado De Sinaloa, A.C. v. United States

Confederación de Asociaciones Agrícolas del Estado De Sinaloa, A.C. v. United States

Asociación Mexicana de Horticultura Protegida, A.C. v. United States

07/07/2020

19-00203

19-00206

20-00036

Choe-Groves 1581(c) & 1581(i)
20-92 Nucor Corp. v. United States 07/02/2020 Consol. 19-00042 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-91 Vicentin S.A.I.C. v. United States
Public version posted 07/09/2020.
07/01/2020 Consol. 18-00111 Kelly 1581(c)
20-90 Borusan Mannesmann Pipe U.S. Inc. v. United States 06/25/2020 20-00012 Baker 1581(i)
20-89 CSC Sugar LLC v. United States 06/25/2020 20-00017 Gordon 1581(c)
20-88 CSC Sugar LLC v.  United States 06/25/2020 20-00016 Gordon 1581(c)
20-87 Habas Sinai ve Tibbi Gazlar Istihsal Endustrisi A.S. v. United States 06/25/2020 Consol. 18-00144 Kelly 1581(c)
20-86 Jiaxing Brother Fastener Co. v. United States 06/22/2020 15-00313 Kelly 1581(c)
20-85 NEXTEEL Co. v. United States 06/17/2020 Consol. 17-00091 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-84 Coal. of Am. Flange Producers v. United States
Public version posted 06/17/2020.
06/17/2020 18-00225 Katzmann 1581(c)
20-83 Canadian Solar Int'l Ltd. v. United States 06/15/2020 Consol. 17-00173 Kelly 1581(c)
20-82 Shanghai Wells Hanger Co. v. United States 06/11/2020 15-00103 Gordon 1581(c)
20-81 Guizhou Tyre Co. v. United States 06/05/2020 Consol. 18-00100 Goldberg 1581(c)
20-80 DAK Americas LLC v. United States
Public version posted 06/04/2020.
06/04/2020 18-00238 Katzmann 1581(c)
20-79

J. Conrad LTD v. United States

Metropolitan Staple Corp. v. United States

06/01/2020

20-00052

20-00053

Stanceu, Choe-Groves, Baker 1581(i)
20-78 Luoyang Bearing Corp. (Grp.) v. United States 06/01/2020 19-00026 Katzmann 1581(c)
20-77 Hilex Poly Co. v. United States 06/01/2020 17-00090 Stanceu 1581(i)
20-76 American Drew v. United States 06/01/2020 17-00086 Stanceu 1581(i)
20-75 Adee Honey Farms v. United States 06/01/2020 Consol. 16-00127 Stanceu 1581(i)
20-74 Lockhart Textiles, Inc. v. United States 05/29/2020 17-00099 Gordon 1581(a)
20-73 Invenergy Renewables LLC v. United States 05/27/2020 19-00192 Katzmann 1581(i)
20-72 ABB Inc. v. United States 05/26/2020 16-00054 Barnett 1581(c)
20-71 Borusan Mannesmann Boru Sanayi ve Ticaret A.S. v. United States
Public version posted 05/22/2020.
05/22/2020 Consol. 19-00056 Restani 1581(c)
20-70 Wirtgen Am., Inc. v. United States 05/18/2020 20-00027 Choe-Groves 1581(a) & 1581(i)
20-69 NEXTEEL Co. v. United States 05/18/2020 Consol. 18-00083 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-68 The Kalencom Corp. v. United States 05/18/2020 15-00011 Reif 1581(a)
20-67 Nat'l Ass'n of Mfrs. v. U.S. Dep't of Treasury 05/15/2020 19-00053 Restani 1581(i)
20-66 United States v. Ho 05/15/2020 19-00038 Reif 1582
20-65 Calgon Carbon Corp. v. United States
Public version posted 05/20/2020.
05/13/2020 Consol. 18-00232 Barnett 1581(c)
20-64 Changzhou Trina Solar Energy Co. v. United States
Public version posted 05/21/2020.
05/13/2020 Consol. 18-00176 Kelly 1581(c)
20-63 T. T. International Co. v. United States 05/11/2020 19-00071 Kelly 1581(c)
20-62 CP Kelco US, Inc. v. United States 05/08/2020 13-00288 Goldberg 1581(c)
20-61 Chemours Co. FC, LLC v. United States
Public version posted 05/14/2020.
05/06/2020 18-00174 Reif 1581(c)
20-60 Dis Vintage LLC v. United States 05/06/2020 16-00013 Reif 1581(a)
20-59 In Zone Brands, Inc. v. United States
Public version posted 05/05/2020.
05/05/2020 17-00025 Restani 1581(a)
20-58 Novolipetsk Steel Pub. Joint Stock Co. v. United States 05/01/2020 19-00194 Kelly 1581(i)
20-57 Goodluck India Ltd. v. United States 04/30/2020 18-00162 Katzmann 1581(c)
20-56 United States v. Ho 04/27/2020 19-00102 Reif 1582
20-55 Jacobi Carbons AB v. United States 04/23/2020 Consol. 16-00185 Barnett 1581(c)
20-54 Jindal Poly Films Ltd. of India v. United States 04/22/2020 19-00050 Kelly 1581(c)
20-53 Nat. Res. Def. Council, Inc. v. United States
Errata: 04/22/2020.
04/22/2020 18-00055 Katzmann 1581(i)
20-52 Shake & Shingle All. v. United States 04/20/2020 18-00228 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-51 Habaş Sinai ve Tibbi Gazlar Istihsal Endüstrisi, A.Ş. v. United States 04/17/2020 Consol. 17-00204 Barnett 1581(c)
20-50 Shenzhen Xinboda Indus. Co. v. United States 04/17/2020 12-00174 Kelly 1581(c)
20-49 United States v. Maverick Mktg., LLC 04/16/2020 Consol. 17-00174 Kelly 1582
20-48 Coal. for Fair Trade in Garlic v. United States 04/14/2020 18-00137 Barnett 1581(c)
20-47 Eregli Demir ve Celik Fabrikalari T.A.S. v. United States 04/13/2020 Consol. 16-00218 Barnett 1581(c)
20-46 Deacero S.A.P.I. de C.V. v. United States
Public version posted 04/23/2020.
04/13/2020 17-00183 Kelly 1581(c)
20-45 Bio-Lab, Inc. v. United States 04/07/2020 18-00155 Eaton 1581(c)
20-44 TMB 440AE, Inc. v. United States 04/06/2020 18-00095 Restani 1581(c)
20-43 Meridian Prods., LLC v. United States 04/06/2020 13-00246 Stanceu 1581(c)
20-42 GODACO Seafood Joint Stock Co. v. United States 04/01/2020 Consol. 18-00063 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-41 BMW of North America LLC v. United States 03/26/2020 15-00052 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-40 Home Depot U.S.A., Inc. v. United States
Public version posted 04/02/2020.
03/26/2020 14-00061 Reif 1581(a)
20-39 Jiangsu Zhongji Lamination Materials Co. v. United States 03/24/2020 18-00089 Restani 1581(c)
20-38 Stupp Corp. v. United States 03/24/2020 Consol. 15-00334 Kelly 1581(c)
20-37 Macao Commercial & Indust. Spring Mattress Mfr. v. United States 03/20/2020 19-00005 Gordon 1581(c)
20-36 Trendium Pool Prods., Inc.  v. United States 03/19/2020 18-00132 Katzmann 1581(c)
20-35 Janssen Ortho LLC v. United States 03/12/2020 13-00296 Choe-Groves 1581(a)
20-34 TR Int'l Trading Co. v. United States 03/16/2020 19-00022 Barnett 1581(i)
20-33 Sumecht NA, Inc. v. United States 03/12/2020 17-00244 Choe-Groves 1581(i)
20-32 Can Tho Imp.-Exp. Joint Stock Co. v. United States
Public version posted 03/20/2020.
03/12/2020 16-00071 Kelly 1581(c)
20-31 Jiangsu Senmao Bamboo & Wood Indus. Co. v. United States 03/11/2020 Consol. 15-00225 Stanceu 1581(c)
20-30 Jiangsu Zhongji Lamination Materials Co., (HK) Ltd. v. United States 03/09/2020 18-00091 Katzmann 1581(c)
20-29 Wirtgen Am., Inc. v. United States 03/04/2020 20-00027 Stanceu 1581(a) & 1581(i)
20-28 Midwest Fastener Corp. v. United States 03/04/2020 17-00231 Kelly 1581(c)
20-27 Bebitz Flanges Works Private Ltd. v. United States 03/03/2020 18-00229 Katzmann 1581(c)
20-26 Bebitz Flanges Works Private Ltd. v. United States
Public version posted 03/10/2020.
03/02/2020 18-00224 Barnett 1581(c)
20-25 Nat'l Ass'n of Mfrs. v. U.S. Dep't of Treasury 02/18/2020 19-00053 Restani 1581(i)
20-24 Bio-Lab, Inc. v. United States
Public version posted 03/05/2020.
02/26/2020 18-00051 Kelly 1581(c)
20-23 Canadian Solar Inc. v. United States
Public version posted 02/25/2020.
02/25/2020 Consol. 18-00184 Restani 1581(c)
20-22 Linyi Chengen Imp. & Exp. Co. v. United States 02/20/2020 Consol. 18-00002 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-21 ABB Inc. v. United States
Public version posted 02/28/2020.
02/19/2020 16-00054 Barnett 1581(c)
20-20 United Steel, Paper & Forestry, Rubber, Mfg., Energy, Allied Indust. & Serv. Workers Int'l Union, AFL-CIO, CLC v. United States 02/18/2020 Consol. 17-00078 Choe-Groves 1581(c)
20-19 Invenergy Renewables LLC v. United States 02/14/2020 19-00192 Katzmann 1581(i)
20-18 Shandong Jinxiang Zhengyang Imp. & Exp. Co. v. United States 02/11/2020 18-00156 Barnett 1581(c)
20-17 United States v. Maverick Mktg., LLC 02/07/2020 Consol. 17-00174 Kelly 1582
20-16 Mid Continent Steel & Wire, Inc. v. United States 02/07/2020 Consol. 15-00213 Kelly 1581(c)
20-15 Uttam Galva Steels Ltd. v. United States 02/06/2020 19-00044 Gordon 1581(c)
20-14 Janssen Ortho LLC v. United States
Errata: 02/19/2020.
02/06/2020 13-00296 Choe-Groves 1581(a)
20-13 Jiaxing Brother Fastener Co. v. United States 02/03/2020 14-00316 Kelly 1581(c)
20-12 M S Int'l v. United States 01/30/2020 Consol. 19-00132 Gordon 1581(i)
20-11 Jiaxing Brother Fastener Co. v. United States 01/29/2020 15-00313 Kelly 1581(c)
20-10 Icdas Celik Enerji Tersane ve Ulasim, A.S. v. United States 01/28/2020 Consol. 18-00143 Katzmann 1581(c)
20-9 Nat'l Ass'n of Mfrs. v. U.S. Dep't of Treasury 01/24/2020 19-00053 Restani 1581(i)
20-8 Asociación de Exportadores e Industriales de Aceitunas de Mesa v. United States 01/17/2020 18-00195 Katzmann 1581(c)
20-7 Sao Ta Foods Joint Stock Co. v. United States
Public version posted 01/24/2020.
01/16/2020 Consol. 18-00205 Kelly 1581(c)
20-6 Aireko Constr., LLC v. United States 01/13/2020 15-00319 Kelly 1581(c)
20-5 China Steel Corp. v. United States 01/09/2020 17-00152 Eaton 1581(c)
20-4 Borusan Mannesmann Boru Sanayi ve Ticaret A.S. v. United States
Public version posted 01/07/2020.
01/07/2020 Consol. 19-00056 Restani 1581(c)
20-3 United States v. Harvic Int'l Ltd. 01/03/2020 16-00273 Gordon 1582
20-2 Husteel Co., Ltd. v. United States
Public version posted 01/13/2020.
01/03/2020 Consol. 18-00169 Kelly 1581(c)
20-1 Amcor Flexibles Singen GmbH v. United States
Public version posted 01/10/2020.
01/03/2020 15-00240 Reif 1581(a)